Broken Link Building: What It Is & How to Do It Right in 2024

Rachel Handley

Jul 03, 20239 min read
Broken Link Building Guide


Broken link building is the process of finding dead links on other websites and convincing web admins to replace them with working links to your website.

A link is “broken,” “dead,” or “invalid” when it points to a page that’s inaccessible. 

Like this:

an illustration of a broken link leading to "we got lost" page

Usually, you’ll look for links to external pages that return 404 Not Found errors. This HTTP status code indicates that the page was deleted. You can offer the linking site an alternative resource to link out to.

However, you can look for other kinds of broken links. And work to inherit them.

Broken link building can be an effective way to earn links from external domains (known as backlinks). 

In addition to driving valuable referral traffic, backlinks can benefit your SEO. Because Google treats certain types of backlinks like votes of confidence. 

The higher the quality and quantity of backlinks you have, the more authoritative your site is perceived to be. And that can lead to higher search engine rankings.

Broken link building can have a higher success rate than other link building tactics. Because you’re helping web admins solve an issue on their site. And providing a reason to link to you. 

Plus, the strategy can help you:

  • Earn backlinks on pages with established traffic and authority
  • Inherit links that previously pointed to competitors
  • Generate link bait ideas (i.e., link-worthy content ideas) 

Learn how to do broken link building step by step:

  1. Identify Your Broken Backlinks
  2. Identify Competitors’ Broken Backlinks
  3. Evaluate Link Opportunities
  4. Identify Outreach Contacts
  5. Send Your Pitch

Let’s get started.

Start by finding dead links that were supposed to point to your website in the first place (i.e., broken backlinks). 

In these cases, you’re more likely to have a viable alternative link. And the admin is more likely to update the link in your favor.

Find broken backlinks with Semrush’s Backlink Audit tool.

Enter your domain and click “Start Backlink Audit.”

Backlink Audit tool with "" in a search bar and "start backlink audit" button highlighted

Then, follow the prompts to configure the Backlink Audit tool.

Once your backlink audit is ready, go to the “Audit” tab. 

“Audit” tab in the Backlink Audit tool

Check the box next to “Target URL error.”

This filters for backlinks that point to 4xx (Client Error) or 5xx (Server Error) pages on your website.

filtering the backlinks that point to 4xx (Client Error) or 5xx (Server Error) pages

Next, go to the “Toxicity Score” filter and select “0-44 Non-toxic.”

This filters out potentially harmful backlinks. Restoring these potentially harmful broken backlinks could harm your site.

“Toxicity Score” filter with a drop down menu to choose from

You now have a list of broken backlinks that could be worth fixing.

Export the results using the “Export to CSV” button. 

“Export to CSV” button highlighted

You can now jump ahead to step three. Or find your competitors’ broken backlinks first.

Tip: Use Semrush’s Link Building Tool to find and recover lost backlinks. This includes broken and removed backlinks. 

When you find competitors’ broken backlinks, you have an opportunity to “steal” them.

There are two main methods:

Let’s explore each tactic step by step.

With Semrush’s Backlink Analytics tool, you can review your competitors’ backlink profiles. And filter for links to broken pages.

To start, enter your domain and click “Analyze.”

Backlink Analytics tool with "" in a search bar and "analyze" button highlighted

Click “...” then “Competitors.”

click on “Competitors" button in the top right corner

The tool provides a list of “Domain Competitors.”

This is based on the number of referring domains pointing to each competitor and the number of referring domains you have in common.

Generally, the more backlinks you already share, the better your chance of inheriting their broken backlinks.

Click on the top competitor’s domain to explore their backlinks.

"Domain Competitors" table with "Competition level" row highlighted

Then, go to the “Indexed Pages” tab.

And apply the “Broken Pages” filter. 

“Broken Pages” filter in Indexed Pages tab

You’ll see a list of 4xx and 5xx pages on the competitor’s site. 

Click the number in the “Backlinks” column to see a breakdown of backlinks to each one.

“Backlinks” column highligted

Filter for “Active” backlinks. Then export your results.

filtering for “Active” backlinks

Repeat this process for other pages and competitors. And combine your exported data in one spreadsheet.

"Competitor Backlinks" exported in Google spreadsheet

You’ll analyze your opportunities in step three.

Some websites have resource pages that contain useful links to external websites. 

If these pages contain dead links, you might be able to inherit them. (Along with any other links to the broken pages.)

Find resource pages using Google. 

Google search operators can help narrow your search. Here are some templates:

  • “useful links” AND [topic]
  • [topic] intitle:“useful resources”
  • [topic] inurl:resources

For example:

Google search for: "useful links" AND real estate New York

Use an extension like Check My Links to find invalid links on resource pages.

Look for broken backlinks you could inherit. Ones that are relevant to your brand.

find broken links in Check My Links

To find out if the broken page has other backlinks you could pursue, copy the broken URL. 

Then, paste it into Semrush’s Backlink Analytics tool and click “Analyze.”

Backlink Analytics tool with "" in a search bar and "analyze" button highlighted

The “Backlinks” tab shows a list of backlinks to the broken page.

Use the “Export” button to save your results in a spreadsheet. You’ll evaluate them in the next step.

“Backlinks” tab shows a list of backlinks to the broken page

Next, evaluate and prioritize your broken link building opportunities. So you can use resources more effectively.

One consideration is the potential value of the backlink.

Gauge this with Semrush’s Authority Score (AS) metric. It measures the authoritativeness of a page or domain on a scale of 0-100.

Generally, the higher the referring page or domain’s score, the more valuable the backlink for SEO.

Sort the “Page AS” and “AS” spreadsheet columns into descending order. 

Backlinks exported in a spreadsheet

Tip: For more ways to evaluate the potential value of a backlink, read our backlink analysis guide.

Next, review each broken link in context

Simply open its source URL and find the hyperlinked element.

broken link highlighted in opened source URL

To find out what the linked page used to look like, enter the dead link into Wayback Machine.

entering a link in Wayback Machine search bar

Then, click the date of the most recent snapshot. You can check earlier dates if you need to. 

click the date of the most recent snapshot in Wayback Machine

When you open the snapshot, you can see the deleted page. And work to find a comparable resource on your website.

example of a deleted page titled "east village history project"

Consider the alternative link you could recommend to the web admin. And the likelihood they'll accept your suggestion.

The web admin is more likely to link to your site if:

  • Your suggested link is relevant and useful in context
  • Your suggested page is the best of its kind
  • Their page gets ample traffic
  • Linking to your site presents no conflict of interest
  • The original link was supposed to point to your site

Tip: Maximize your chance of success by improving your content. Or creating quality content from scratch. But you’ll need to weigh the potential benefits against the effort required.

Conversely, the web admin is less likely to link to your site if:

  • They can easily find a better alternative
  • Their content is outdated (e.g., an old news article)
  • Linking to your site presents a conflict of interest (e.g., you’re a competitor)
  • The original link was sponsored or pointed to a partner site
  • The original link appears within user-generated content (e.g., a forum comment)

In these cases, the admin might decide to link elsewhere, leave the dead link in place, or remove it altogether.

So, pursuing these broken link building opportunities could do more harm than good. You’ll waste time and potentially harm relationships with useful contacts.

Decide whether the opportunity is worth pursuing and add notes to your spreadsheet.

Like this:

"Notes" highlighted in a speadsheet

When you’re ready to pursue one or more opportunities, move to the next step.

4. Identify Outreach Contacts

Outreach is the process of contacting web admins (usually via email) and requesting that they link to your site. 

In broken link building, the idea is to point out the broken backlink. And offer your alternative.

First, determine whom to contact. 

Staff writers typically have the motive and power to update dead links. Open the source page’s URL to check for an author byline.

You might need to check the writer’s author page or social media profiles to learn more about them.

Let’s say you’re pursuing a broken link building SEO opportunity in this article:

an example of article "Pitch for the check you want" with its author highlighted below

Natasha’s author page shows that she’s a staff writer. And even includes her email address.

an author page for "Natasha Mascarenhas"

You could even try direct messaging her on Twitter.

"Natasha Mascarenhas" on Twitter

If that tactic doesn’t work, check the site’s “Contact” or “Meet the Team” page.

Look for a specific contact (a particular person’s email address) rather than a generic email address (like Direct requests to the most relevant person are more likely to succeed.

Tip: For help finding an email address, try Prowly. The tool’s media database contains over 1 million contacts. And you can search by name or website.

example of a profile for "Ingrid Lunden" with contact information in Prowly.

5. Send Your Pitch

Next, write and send your pitch. 

Admins are often receptive to broken link building emails. After all, you’re bringing their attention to an issue on their website. And providing a suggestion to help them fix it.

You’ve ensured your alternative link is a good fit and identified the right contact. All that’s left is making a clear, friendly, and compelling proposal.

Here are some best practices:

  • Start with a personalized greeting
  • Reference the broken link upfront
  • Explain why your link makes a good alternative
  • Include hyperlinks for easy reference
  • Keep your email concise

Here’s a broken link building email example:

Hi Michael,

I noticed your Dunder Mifflin article “How to Make Your Office More Economical” contains a broken link.

Looks like EcoMag deleted their paper recycling report, as the URL brings up a 404 error.

If you’re looking for an alternative, we’ve just published a new paper waste report here at WasteCo.

We found that offices recycle just 40% of paper on average!

Kind regards,


After sending your email, keep an eye out for a reply. Or an update to the broken link.

If there’s no change after three working days, follow up in the original email thread. Just ask the contact whether they’ve had a chance to consider your proposal.

Alternatively, simplify the entire broken link building process using Semrush’s Link Building Tool.

After setting up your campaign and connecting your email account, head over to the “In Progress” tab.

Scroll down and click “Import.”

“In Progress” tab in Link Building Tool

Select “General” as the outreach strategy.

Enter the referring domains selected for broken link building and click “Add” > “Add new domains.”

"Add domains to your In Progress list" page

Next, find the site you want to email and click “Contact.”

find “Contact” button on the right side of the site

On this page, you’ll draft a broken link building outreach email.

You can even save it as a template.

a box to draft a broken link building outreach email

Once you’ve written the email, click “Send and proceed to next.”

“Send and proceed to next” button below email

The tool will automatically update the “Status” column.

You can see whether your email has been sent, delivered, read, or replied to. 

“Status” column shows updates on your email has been sent, delivered, read, or replied to

Ideally, you’ll eventually see the notification, “Backlink earned.”

“Backlink earned” notification

Go to the “Monitor” report to learn more about your backlink and ensure it remains active.

“Monitor” report

Tip: Semrush’s Link Building Tool finds other link building prospects based on your target keywords and competitors. Check them out in the “Prospects” report.

Broken link building is just one way to earn backlinks that drive SEO results and referral traffic. To build a healthy backlink profile, employ a variety of link building tactics.

To keep learning, check out these resources:

Or find missed backlink opportunities with Semrush’s Backlink Gap tool. It shows which domains link to your competitors, but not to you.

You can easily review prospects and send your favorite opportunities to the Link Building Tool.

Author Photo
Rachel has been a digital marketer for over 11 years. Having worked both in-house and agency-side, she has a wide range of experiences to draw on in her writing. She specializes in creating beginner-friendly articles on topics including keyword research, on-page SEO, and content creation.
More on this