Tom Casano

How to Generate 3x More Leads and Optimize for Profit With SEO

Do you want to earn more money from your website by doing the least amount of SEO work required?

I do.

In this article, I will show you how to use your own data to find the profit centers of your website and where you need to focus your resources to make more money from your SEO efforts. I will be using an example of a lead generation website, but the principles carry over fairly well to e-commerce, saas, and other businesses as well.

You Don’t Need More Traffic

Not all traffic is created equal. In fact, for many businesses, most of their sales volume is coming from the top 5% or less of all of their web traffic.

If you want to grow your business’s revenue and earnings: You don’t need more traffic; you need more of the right traffic. The problem is that the bottom-of-funnel, ready-to-buy, money keywords are the most competitive, so SEOs go after the less competitive, more top-of-funnel keywords. The only thing wrong with this is that it might not provide the highest ROI.

You don’t need more traffic; you need more of the right traffic.

Using Your Data to Make More Money

For our example in this article, I will be using the website LifeCoachSpotter.com, which is a lead generation website for life coaches. The business makes money by generating and selling leads to life coaches.

Find Leads Who Need Your Services

Close more deals in no time

Please specify a valid domain, e.g., www.example.com Please specify a valid domain, e.g., www.example.com

Assigning a Value to Conversions

To earn more money with your website, you need to first understand where you are currently making money on your website with SEO – specifically which pages and which keywords. And to do that, you will need to set up conversion tracking in your analytics platform.

If you don’t already have conversion tracking set up in Google Analytics, follow these steps. Once your goals are set up and working, make sure that you have assigned a dollar value to each goal completion. Even if your website generates leads with an unknown exact value for each lead, do the math for your business and assign it the value that each lead is worth on average. We are aiming for an estimate here, not perfection.

Google Analytics won’t retroactively assign the values to your conversions on your past data. So you will have to wait for enough new data to come in, or you can just use the number of leads in the meantime.

Finding Your Money Pages

In Google Analytics, go to Behavior > Site Content > Landing Pages.

Set your segment to “Organic Traffic”.

Choose the goal that most accurately represents your earnings.

Sort it by “Lead Submitted (Goal # Value)”

What you have now is a work of art.

Where The Money Is Made

When you spend a few minutes looking at this data and interpreting it, it doesn’t take you very long to start drawing a few conclusions.

For this particular website (LifeCoachSpotter.com), you can see on that top right that 42% of all the money and leads generated came from just one page on the website. And when you realize that this one webpage is targeting keywords like “find a life coach” and “how to find a life coach”, it all makes sense. The user intent is so high that the conversion rate is comparatively through the roof, at 5.6%.

You also realize something else:

Traffic ≠ Money

When you look at the 3rd page listed, you see that even though this one page accounts for 39% of all organic traffic to this website, it only contributes 15% of the revenue.

Even though this one page accounts for 39% of all organic traffic to this website, it only contributes 15% of the revenue.

Why?

The conversion rate is a mere 0.28%. That is only a fraction of the conversion rate of the first page, which at 5.6%, is 20 times the conversion rate of this page. The conversion rate on this page is so low because the user intent is so low. This page is targeting keywords like “feeling lost in life” and “how to find yourself.” While a user searching on Google for this keyword might convert into a lead looking for a life coach, they don’t have the same intent as someone who searches “find a life coach”. The differences are staggering.

Traffic does not equal money.

The page with the most traffic – at 65,000 organic visitors – only creates a third of the value of a page with only 9,000 visitors.

Revenue Generated = Traffic x Conversion Rate x Value Per Lead

You don’t need more traffic; you need more of the right traffic.

Identifying and Optimizing Your Real Money Keywords

Now that you know the most important pages for making your business money, you need to find out what are the keywords that people are coming to these pages from.

Google Analytics doesn’t play nice, but this data is easy to get from Google Search Console.

In the new Google Search Console, go to Performance and then filter for the page you want to find the keywords that you are getting impressions for.

Scroll down, sort by Impressions, and behold your treasure trove of the exact keywords you can now optimize for.

Export this list and spend some time with it.

Are these keywords already in your page and content? Are there long-tail keywords you can easily add into your title tag, header tags, or body text?

If you have a long list of keywords, you can use a free and fun tool like Word Frequency Counter to see which terms keep reappearing the most.

Go through your existing content and see if there are natural places you can optimize by adding in certain phrases or keywords to help this page rank better for the lower-volume but high-converting keywords. You might even decide that it is worth adding sections of 100-300 words to discuss one of these new keywords as a more in-depth subtopic.

Your Sole SEO Focus: These Pages

Now you are empowered to focus your time, effort and energy into your most high-value pages. You might even go back to Google Analytics and find the pages that have high conversion rates (even if they don’t have high traffic currently, as they might be ranking low but have more potential as well).

Rather than merely trying to get more traffic which won’t equate into earnings for you, you can now focus your SEO resources into these most important pages. There are several ranking factors that you can make aggressive investments into. For example:

  • Content: Make the content better, longer, more helpful, more engaging, etc.

  • Link Building: Start earning/building more backlinks to this page from other websites.

  • Internal Linking: Starting linking to this page more from your other pages and use relevant anchor text.

  • User Experience: Help to satisfy user intent and provide better visuals, look and feel, and an overall better user experience.

There are many more ranking factors you can look at for this page (and any SEO knows that the list is endless). Page speed, bounce rate, keyword density, etc.

Think of the 80/20 rule. 80% of your resources should be going into the 20% of the pages that will drive 80% of your results.

Beyond the Marketing Funnel

You want to track conversions all the way through the sales funnel, right up through the conversion into a sale.

To fully maximize your ability to earn money from your website, you need to go beyond your website and into your sales funnel.

Correlate your leads with the pages or keywords that they have come from. Attribute which leads are closing with your sales team into deals and customers. Identify if specific pages are creating sales leads that are less likely to close and if other pages are generating leads that are more likely to close.

The only way to effectively do this is with more data.

If you can use the data in your CRM to identify which closed deals are coming from which web pages, then you can effectively see which pages are actually making you the most money (regardless of traffic or number of leads converted).

Conclusion

Superficially, many business owners and entrepreneurs start out by looking at the wrong KPIs. These initial KPIs are things like: “I want to rank higher for this keyword” or “I want to get more traffic”. While these two KPIs could be the right ones, the only real way to know is to look at the existing data and see what it is already working. That is where the greatest opportunity for a high ROI on your SEO investment exists. If there is not enough current traffic to analyze conversion data, then we should begin by getting you some traffic in the first place. But then again, traffic alone is not enough. We need the right kind of traffic. Traffic that will convert.

What is your take?

Leave a comment below and let me know your approach and if you have other methodologies, tools, or analytics insights to improve upon this process.

And if you need help finding the best opportunities to earn more money from your business, I am more than happy to help, just send me a message.

I agree with you, must focus with the keywords that already existing probably just need some effective techniques and focus on it.
Hi Tom,

Thanks for sharing this great information but I have a question that can we use some black hat SEO techniques to rank a temporary site?
Hi Tom,

One of friends and Friends is doing a lead gen business in Tour & Travel domain for USA & Canada clients, he generates the leads from USA and Canada and sales out them in USA & Canada only. I also want to start the same, can you please suggest that from where I can get the more info and how can I start it, any suggestion and info would be really helpful for me.

Thank you so much in advance!!

Regards,
Ravi
Nice work Tom. Advanced Google Analytics KPI is a challenge for most people. I highly recommend for SEO professionals to take the Google Analytics course in Google Academy.
Daniel H.
Thanks so much Dan! I really appreciate the kind words and that's a great suggestion. Keep in touch, you rock. :)
Really specific and helpful ideas. I can follow this myself, Simple, but not easy. You also gave me a great idea for a website. Thanks for the good information
Roma Kapadiya
Hey Roma! Thanks for the positive feedback. You're very welcome and happy to help!
Tom, you are absolutely right, we don't need traffic, we need the 'right' traffic that will convert.

Also, you know Google Analytics has an abundant amount of database, and it's a tough job to find the metrics that are important to us. One of them is setting the right achievable goals, and I appreciate the fact that you have clarified doing so at the beginning of the post.

Thank you for the useful insights and valuable advice.
Sahil Kakkar
Thank so much for your comment and kind words. It really means a lot to me and I really appreciate your support. Keep in touch!
Tom, thank you for your advices and the time to write this article. Identifying is now simple, but we all must optimize our landing pages - this is the hardest part. Will be nice to see some explanation from expert, example working for small sites. A/B testing so many times is a waste of time if I have small amount of data - I mean small number of visitors for current site.
Eduard Dimitrov
Hi Eduard, thank you for the kind comment! Yes, when optimizing a landing page for SEO, I typically focus on:

-page title
-URL slug
-header tags
-body text
-meta description

...And of course, satisfying user intent and overall UX.

I hope that helps!

Tom
Eduard Dimitrov
Absolutely. Landing pages are the most important aspect. If your landing page does not match your ad, Google will likely lower your Trust Score. The mismatch is ad copy vs landing page copy will lessen your conversion ability.
Great one tom but tell me how White Hat SEO helps in getting you more conversion? Help me with that
Aman Rai
Hi Aman! White hat SEO doesn't help you get more conversion per se -- But white hat SEO is ethical and will endure for the long-term, thus it's the best way to go for SEO instead of doing something spammy that gets penalized in 6 months. There's no point in investing in SEO if you're not going to get long-term ROI in my opinion.
Thank you for sharing, the article is very useful
Bigatm
You're very welcome Bigatm! :)
Thanks for sharing this in-depth piece, Tom!

Setting up conversion "Goals" in Analytics for each blog posts is one of the most underrated topics in the world of SEO. Without this step, it is equivalent to shooting in the dark. Each post should have a relevant CTA and conversion point (even if the CTA is a phone call) and data should be continuously collected. It is the first step in proving your SEO ROI.
Kelechi Ibe
Thanks for sharing this Kelechi! I'm happy to hear you feel this way. The majority of clients/companies who think of and use SEO think of it from an acquisition standpoint vs a conversion standpoint. Great great point on proving your SEO ROI! I'd love to hear more about how you do this and what work you've done in this area. Keep in touch!
Tom Casano
Well put Tom. Conversion is where you make the money. Not the acquisition.
Agree "You don’t need more traffic; you need more of the right traffic."
Anand Joshi
Thanks Anand! Getting a high volume of traffic is tempting though! :)
Anand Joshi
Concise and to the point. Well stated Anand.
Daniel H.
Thanks for your comment Daniel.
i've tried all this before but the results were dam horrible
CJ
Hi CJ, I'm sorry to hear that... I wonder why. Is it due to not enough authoritative backlinks or why weren't you able to optimize for the pages that already generate the most leads to get more traffic from them? I'm happy to help. :)
Its really very good post.excellent. thanx
Amandip Hkaurr
You're welcome Amandip! Thanks for the comment and glad you liked it. :)
Brilliant, so informative. Great post Tom! I especially like the concept of focusing on the right kind of traffic to convert. I also enjoyed checking out your website. Hope to read more posts from you here!
Edmund Zaloga
Thanks so much Ed! That is so kind of you to say, I really appreciate it. You are the best! :)
SEO will stay relevant and important because it transcends standard search moving into voice and voice assistants directly pulling information through markup on websites. Great article. Keep them coming.
Roman Prokopchuk
Thanks so much Roman! I really appreciate it. :)
Awesome sauce dude. Awesome. Sauce. ;) Great piece!
C. Alex Velazquez
Thanks so much Alex! I'm really glad you enjoyed it. :)
Add a comment